How does the view of ethical cause
and effect in history in Works and Days compare with the
furies' view in The Eumenides?
Works
and Days
by Hesiod provides an interesting comparison to Aeschylus' Eumenides,
since both works of literature deal with many of the same themes of
revenge, honesty, hard work, and ethics. Works
and Days
attempts to teach the reader what actions will lead to a good life
(as well as what actions will lead to a poor and unhappy life).
Eumenides,
although it uses much the same concept, is more focused and candid in
its warnings of a bad life rather than promises of a good.
In
Works and Days,
Hesiod admits that it is morally permissible to take revenge on
someone if they have wronged you. Eumenides
agrees with this idea, as two major characters of the play use
revenge to get back at those who have wronged them. Clytemnestra's
husband sacrifices their daughter, so in revenge Clytemnestra commits
adultery with another man and later kills her husband. Her son
Orestes, once he finds out what his mother has done, takes revenge on
her by killing her. Eumenides
deals with which revenge was correct. According to the Furies, who
play a major part in Eumenides,
it was Clytemnestra's, and they spend most of the play trying to get
Orestes punished for his revenge against his mother.
Honesty
is dealt with in both Works
and Days
and Eumenides.
Hesiod believes that being honest is one of the actions that will
result in a good and happy life. Morally speaking, being honest is
the right thing to do under any circumstance, and this is illustrated
in Eumenides
when Orestes decides to be honest in the face of the Furies'
condemnation about why he killed his mother.
Hard
work is also an important part of both pieces of literature. Hesiod
points out, through many different examples, how hard work will pay
off and lead to a good and happy life. Hard work, he says, will make
one comfortable at the very least and may even lead to wealth, if
applied correctly. He gives ideas on how to apply the principles of
hard work to one's life, explaining in detail how to make the most of
one's resources and labor. Hard work certainly paid off for the
Furies in Eumenides.
Although their primary goal – which was to have Orestes punished
for the murder of his mother – was not achieved, they succeeded in
becoming revered gods of Athens, an outcome which the city had
offered to them as a sort of compromise.
Works
and Days
and The Eumenides
are filled with many such similarities and contrasts. They are
fascinating complements to each other, and of course, they are
outstanding works of literature in their own right.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.